How to Host a Holiday Cookie Decorating Party

the ultimate hostess guide to entertaining at home

Join our Glam Tribe where you receive weekly updates and instantly unlock the Elevated 4-Phase Host Collection.

The Ultimate Hostess Guide To Entertaining At Home Freebie

How to Host a Holiday Cookie Decorating Party

There is something about getting together with girlfriends during the holidays that just feels special. Add a little Christmas music, festive cocktails, cozy sweaters, and freshly baked sugar cookies waiting to be decorated, and you've got the makings of a really fun holiday gathering!

A holiday cookie decorating party is a great way to bring everyone together for an afternoon or evening of creativity, laughter, and a little friendly competition. And the best part? You don't have to be an expert cookie decorator to enjoy it.

Whether you're planning a small gathering around your dining room table or turning your home into a festive cookie decorating studio, a little preparation will go a long way toward making the experience enjoyable for everyone.

A few holiday cookies from my former cookie decorating business days. Don't worry, your party cookies don't have to look like this to be fun!

Decorated Christmas sugar cookies for a holiday cookie decorating party, arranged around a Merry & Bright plaque cookie

Here are my tips for hosting a holiday cookie decorating party that your girlfriends will be talking about long after the last cookie has been eaten! This post contains affiliate links. If you buy through them, I may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you.

1. Pick a Fun Holiday Theme

Let's start with the fun part! While a traditional Christmas cookie decorating party is always a good idea, why not give your gathering a little personality?

One idea I absolutely love is an Ugly Christmas Sweater Cookie Decorating Party.

Invite your girlfriends to wear their favorite (or most outrageous!) ugly Christmas sweaters and make sweater-shaped sugar cookies the star of the party. You can even turn the decorating into a friendly competition by having everyone decorate three cookies and vote on their favorites.

You could award prizes for categories like:

  • Most Creative Cookie
  • Funniest Christmas Sweater
  • Most Festive Design
  • Best Overall Cookie

Of course, you don't have to go with the ugly sweater theme. Christmas trees, gingerbread people, snowflakes, ornaments, and candy canes are all great cookie shapes to incorporate.

The goal is to create a fun, relaxed atmosphere where everyone can enjoy themselves, whether they're artistic or simply there for the cookies and cocktails!

Plain sweater-shaped sugar cookies with icing bags and sprinkles ready to decorate

2. Bake Your Cookies Ahead of Time

 

If there's one thing I would recommend, it's baking your cookies from scratch.

I know purchasing pre-made sugar cookies might seem like an easier option, but freshly baked sugar cookies really do make a difference. You'll want cookies that are sturdy enough to decorate, hold their shape, and taste delicious when everyone is finished.

For sugar cookies, one of my favorite recipes is the Vanilla 2.0 Sugar Cookie Recipe by Lila Loa. This was my go-to recipe, and it's a great option for decorated sugar cookies.

Get the Vanilla 2.0 Sugar Cookie Recipe from Lila Loa

I would recommend preparing your dough ahead of time, rolling it out, cutting your shapes, and baking the cookies before your guests arrive. You don't want to spend your party baking cookies when you could be enjoying time with your girlfriends!

Once baked and completely cooled, store the cookies in airtight containers until you're ready to set up your decorating station.

A little tip: Make a few extra cookies. Between taste testing and the occasional decorating mishap, you'll be glad you have them!


3. Prepare Your Royal Icing

Now let's talk icing!

Royal icing is what gives decorated sugar cookies that beautiful, smooth finish and allows you to create different designs, layers, and details.

There are several royal icing recipes available online, and a traditional royal icing will work perfectly fine for a cookie decorating party.

However, when I owned my cookie decorating business, I used a recipe by Sweet Hope that combines traditional royal icing with a sweet glaze. Sometimes referred to as a hybrid icing or "Frankenfrosting," this recipe creates a smooth, shiny finish that sets on the outside while maintaining a softer bite.

I particularly loved this icing because it didn't dry rock hard like traditional royal icing, but it still set firmly enough to accommodate multiple layers and decorative details.

If you're interested in trying it, here's the recipe I used.

Sweet Hope Hybrid Royal Icing

Ingredients

Royal Icing Portion

  • 1 pound (453g) powdered sugar
  • 1½ tablespoons meringue powder
  • 1¼ tablespoons water
  • 1 teaspoon pure vanilla extract (you can increase to 2 teaspoons or use lemon emulsion)
  • 2 teaspoons glycerin (optional, for a slightly softer bite)

Sweet Glaze Portion

  • 1 pound (453g) powdered sugar
  • ¼ cup light corn syrup
  • ¼ cup water
  • 1 teaspoon pure vanilla extract (or another flavoring)
  • 1 teaspoon white food coloring gel (optional)

Instructions

Step 1: Make the Royal Icing

  1. In a mixer fitted with the paddle attachment, mix the meringue powder into 1 pound of powdered sugar until thoroughly combined.
  2. On low speed, add the water, vanilla, and glycerin.
  3. Turn the mixer to medium and whip just until the icing becomes fluffy and holds a firm peak.
  4. Remove the royal icing and place it in a separate bowl. Cover the surface with a damp kitchen towel to keep it from drying out. You don't need to clean the mixer bowl.

Step 2: Make the Sweet Glaze

  1. In the same mixer bowl, add the glaze ingredients in this order: powdered sugar, corn syrup, water, vanilla, and white coloring gel.
  2. Beat on low speed until combined.
  3. Turn to medium and beat for 2–3 minutes until smooth and the consistency of thick honey. Stop halfway through to scrape down the sides and bottom of the bowl.

Step 3: Combine the Two

  1. Add the prepared royal icing back into the bowl with the sweet glaze.
  2. Mix on low for 30 seconds.
  3. Use a spatula to scrape down the sides and bottom of the bowl.
  4. Mix on low for another 30–60 seconds until everything is completely combined.

You now have Sweet Hope's hybrid icing!

For a cookie decorating party, I would prepare the icing ahead of time and divide it into piping bags in your desired colors. This makes setting up the decorating stations much easier.

 

4. Gather Your Cookie Decorating Supplies

You don't need an elaborate collection of cookie decorating tools to host a successful party, but there are a few essentials that will make things easier for your guests.

Here are the supplies I recommend:

  1. Tipless Piping Bags

These are a must! Tipless piping bags allow guests to decorate without needing traditional piping tips. Simply fill the bags with icing and snip the end to create an opening.

  1. Christmas Sprinkles

You can't have a Christmas cookie decorating party without sprinkles! Look for a variety of holiday colors, shapes, and sizes. You can find these at grocery stores, Amazon, Hobby Lobby, Michaels, and other craft stores. If you are looking for sprinkles that are more unique and something more than what you may find in the craft stores, try Etsy. The glittery ones you see in the image below came from Delta Sprinkles on Etsy. 

  1. Edible Glitter

A little sparkle makes everything more festive! Edible glitter is a fun way to add some extra pizzazz to decorated cookies.

Just make sure the packaging specifically identifies the product as edible.

  1. Edible Decorating Pens

These edible decorating pens are great for adding little details, writing messages, or drawing designs once the icing has set.

  1. Parchment Paper or Paper Plates

Give each guest a designated surface to decorate their cookies. This helps keep the table clean and gives everyone their own little workspace.

  1. Cookie Take-Home Boxes

You'll want something for everyone to package up their beautiful creations and take them home. Small bakery boxes or cookie boxes are perfect.

  1. Christmas Cookie Cutters

Choose a variety of holiday shapes that coordinate with your theme. Christmas trees, snowflakes, ornaments, gingerbread people, and sweater shapes are all fun options.

  1. Cookie Scribes

These little tools are extremely helpful when decorating cookies. They're used to spread icing into tight spaces, smooth out icing, and pop air bubbles.

These are my favorite scribe tools:

  1. Gel Food Coloring

If you're making your own icing, you'll need gel food coloring to create your desired shades.

I would suggest purchasing a few basic colors rather than buying an entire collection. Red, green, white, and black are great starting points for Christmas decorating.

You can find gel food coloring at Hobby Lobby, Michaels, and online.

  1. Scissors and Tweezers

Have several pairs of small, sharp scissors available so guests can snip the ends of their tipless piping bags. This is a small detail that's easy to overlook! And don’t forget the tweezers which makes it easy for guests to pick up the sprinkles. 

Want it all in one place? Many of these supplies can be picked up at your local craft store, like Hobby Lobby or Michaels. But for convenience, I've also put together an Amazon shopping list with every supply mentioned above, from the tipless piping bags and cookie scribes to the edible glitter and gel food coloring. Shop my cookie decorating essentials and you'll have everything you need for your party in just a few clicks!

Christmas cookie decorating supplies including cookie cutters, piping bags, gel food coloring, edible markers and sprinkles

5. Set Up Individual Cookie Decorating Stations 

This is where you can really make the party feel special!

Rather than having everyone reach across the table for shared supplies, I would set up an individual decorating station for each guest.

Think of it as a little cookie decorating place setting.

Each guest should have:

  • A few freshly baked sugar cookies
  • Their own assortment of colored icing bags
  • A small bowl or container of Christmas sprinkles
  • A cookie scribe
  • A pair of scissors
  • A parchment-lined decorating surface or paper plate

Arrange everything at a dining room table or another table large enough to accommodate your guests comfortably.

I love the idea of having each place setting coordinated with the overall Christmas theme. You can incorporate festive napkins, small holiday details, and even personalized place cards.

It doesn't have to be elaborate. A little thoughtfulness in how you arrange everything makes the experience feel much more intentional.

 

6. Serve Festive Cocktails and Light Refreshments

Let's not forget about the food and drinks!

Since this is a gathering of girlfriends, I would keep the menu fairly simple with light appetizers, cocktails, and a festive beverage station.

A hot chocolate or coffee bar would be a wonderful addition, especially if guests plan to enjoy some of their freshly decorated cookies before heading home.

For the beverage station, consider offering:

  • Hot chocolate with whipped cream, marshmallows, and chocolate shavings
  • Coffee with flavored syrups and seasonal creamers
  • A signature Christmas cocktail
  • Sparkling water or festive nonalcoholic beverages

For food, think easy-to-eat appetizers that won't require guests to leave their decorating stations for too long.

A small charcuterie board, cheese and crackers, mini sandwiches, or a few bite-sized appetizers would be perfect.

You don't need to prepare a full meal. The focus is on the experience, the cookies, and enjoying time together!

Christmas tree shaped charcuterie board holding desserts and cocktail

7. Add a Little Friendly Competition

If you decide to go with the Ugly Christmas Sweater Cookie Decorating theme, a decorating contest is almost a must!

Give everyone three or so sweater-shaped cookies and let their creativity take over.

You might be surprised by what your girlfriends come up with!

Set up a designated area where everyone can display their finished cookies. Once everyone is done, let the group vote on their favorites.

You could even have a few inexpensive prizes for the winners.

And don't forget to take pictures! Capture the decorating process, the finished cookies, everyone showing off their creations, and of course, a group photo of everyone in their festive sweaters.

Put on some Christmas music, pour another cocktail, and enjoy the moment.

Decorated ugly Christmas sweater cookies with a snowman, a Christmas tree and

8. Don't Forget the Little Details 

A few thoughtful touches can take your gathering from a simple cookie decorating activity to a really memorable holiday get-together.

Here are a few ideas:

  • Send a festive invitation: A mobile Evite with an Ugly Christmas Sweater Cookie Decorating theme would be adorable. Encourage everyone to wear their favorite holiday sweater.
  • Create a cocktail station: Set up a small table with your signature cocktail, glassware, napkins, and festive decorations.
  • Style the place settings: Give each guest their own decorating supplies and add a few pretty Christmas details to make the table feel inviting.
  • Package cookies beautifully: Have take-home cookie boxes ready so everyone can transport their creations home.
  • Send guests home with a little something: Party favors aren't necessary, especially when you're already purchasing all the decorating supplies, but a small holiday favor would be a nice finishing touch.

Remember, you don't have to do everything. Choose a few details that make the gathering feel special without creating more work for yourself.

9. Plan Ahead So You Can Enjoy Your Party  

One of the biggest mistakes hosts make is leaving too much preparation until the day of the event.

For a cookie decorating party, I would start preparing approximately 48 hours ahead of time.

Here's how I would break it down:

48 Hours Before

  • Prepare your sugar cookie dough.
  • Roll out, cut, and bake your cookies.
  • Allow cookies to cool completely.
  • Store baked cookies in airtight containers.

24 Hours Before

  • Prepare your royal icing.
  • Divide icing into individual tipless piping bags.
  • Arrange bags by color and store appropriately in the refrigerator.
  • Gather your decorating supplies.
  • Prepare your cookie boxes and other table accessories.

One Hour Before Guests Arrive

  • Remove icing bags from the refrigerator.
  • Gently squeeze each bag to redistribute the icing in case any liquid has settled.
  • Set up individual decorating stations.
  • Arrange your food and beverage stations.
  • Turn on the Christmas music and get the cocktails ready!

By doing most of the work ahead of time, you'll have more time to enjoy your guests instead of running around trying to get everything together.

And don't worry too much about the mess. In my experience, adults generally don't make nearly as much of a mess decorating cookies as children do!

Let the Holiday Fun Begin!

A holiday cookie decorating party doesn't have to be complicated or expensive to be memorable.

It's really about creating an opportunity to slow down during an otherwise busy holiday season, gather your favorite people, and enjoy a little creativity and conversation.

With freshly baked cookies, a few decorating supplies, festive cocktails, and some Christmas music, you have everything you need for a fun afternoon or evening with your girlfriends.

And if you're new to cookie decorating, don't be intimidated! There are plenty of videos and blogs online that walk you through preparing sugar cookies, making royal icing, and decorating different designs. Spend a little time watching a few tutorials before your party so you feel comfortable with the process.

Now, who's ready to put on an ugly Christmas sweater, pour a cocktail, and decorate some cookies?

Meet Leigh

For more than 30 years, I’ve been bringing people together through events and experiences—from conferences, trade shows, networking events and galas to milestone celebrations, themed parties and everything in between.

 

Celebrate

DIY & Decor

Entertaining

Inspiration

Stop Second-Guessing. Start Celebrating.

Bring your inspiration to a 60-minute virtual session with Leigh and leave with a clear direction for a celebration your guests will never forget. Reserve your Party Vision Session for $197; after purchase, you’ll receive a questionnaire and a link to schedule your meeting.

the ultimate
hostess guide to
entertaining at home